Solved
Shut the Box strategy and odds
Tap tiles to open or shut them, then pick the roll.
The short answer
You can't win every time. Good play shuts a 9-tile box about 1 in 10 games and leaves 11 points on average. Three rules of thumb get you most of the way there:
- Shut the highest tiles you can.
- When one tile and a pair clear the same points, take the single tile.
- Once the 7, 8 and 9 are down, think about rolling one die.
The exact numbers
Every figure below comes from an exact solver: it works backwards from every possible set of open tiles and every roll, using the real two-dice probabilities, so no simulation noise. The same tables run the hint button and the hard computer player in the game.
| Tiles | One-die rule | Avg score, best play | Shut chance (best play for score) | Shut chance (best play to shut) | Avg, "always take the highest tile" |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 | optional | 11.01 | 9.67% (1 in 10) | 9.76% (1 in 10) | 11.23 |
| 9 | must | 11.66 | 6.95% (1 in 14) | 7.42% (1 in 13) | 12.27 |
| 9 | never | 11.16 | 7.09% (1 in 14) | 7.14% (1 in 14) | 11.37 |
| 10 | optional | 16.57 | 5.30% (1 in 19) | 5.38% (1 in 19) | 16.81 |
| 10 | must | 16.89 | 3.93% (1 in 25) | 4.19% (1 in 24) | 17.24 |
| 12 | optional | 35.08 | 0.47% (1 in 214) | 0.47% (1 in 211) | 35.34 |
| 12 | must | 35.09 | 0.37% (1 in 268) | 0.39% (1 in 254) | 35.37 |
| 12 | never | 35.08 | 0.36% (1 in 281) | 0.36% (1 in 276) | 35.35 |
"Best play for score" means every decision aims for the lowest average score. "Best play to shut" aims only at a perfect round and doesn't care how bad a failure gets. The two differ a little, because the safest way to a low score isn't always the way to zero.
Why other sites give different odds
Look up the odds of shutting the box and you will find "about 1 in 14" on one site and "about once in 10" on another, for the same 9-tile box. Shut the Box Online publishes the first, Game On Family the second. Both are right. They are playing different one-die rules.
When the single die is compulsory once 7, 8 and 9 are gone, the best possible chance of shutting is 7.42% (1 in 13), and the best average score is 11.66. When it is optional, the chance rises to 9.76% (1 in 10) and the average falls to 11.01. Our solver reproduces both published figures exactly, which is a decent check that all three of us got the maths right. So when you quote odds, say which rule you mean. The one-die rule section of the rules has the wording.
Rules of thumb that get you most of the way
- Shut high tiles first. A 9 only goes down on a roll of 9 or more: alone on a 9, or with a small tile on a 10, 11 or 12. A 1 fits into almost anything.
- One tile beats two when both clear the same points. On an 8, shut the 8 rather than 5+3. You keep more small tiles for the end.
- Get below 7. Once nothing above 6 is open you can roll a single die, which can make 1 to 6 evenly. With few small tiles left, one die is usually the better roll. The calculator above tells you exactly when.
- Big opening rolls. On a full 1-9 box under the optional rule, take 1+9 on a 10, 2+9 on an 11, 3+9 on a 12. Under the "must" rule, if you are chasing a perfect game, the solver switches to 4+6 on a 10 and 5+6 on an 11.
One die or two?
Once every open tile is 6 or lower, the optional rule lets you choose. The answer depends on what is left. Here are some common end positions on a 9-tile box, with the average final score from each choice under best play:
| Open tiles | Avg, roll two dice | Avg, roll one die | Roll |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1.00 | 0.83 | one die |
| 2 | 1.94 | 1.67 | one die |
| 1, 2 | 2.77 | 1.92 | one die |
| 3 | 2.83 | 2.50 | one die |
| 1, 3 | 3.49 | 2.56 | one die |
| 1, 2, 3 | 3.91 | 1.69 | one die |
| 4 | 3.67 | 3.33 | one die |
| 1, 4 | 4.10 | 3.19 | one die |
| 5 | 4.44 | 4.17 | one die |
| 6 | 5.17 | 5.00 | one die |
| 1, 6 | 4.98 | 5.64 | two dice |
| 3, 4 | 5.25 | 5.64 | two dice |
| 1, 2, 4 | 3.65 | 2.46 | one die |
| 2, 6 | 5.93 | 6.44 | two dice |
| 1, 2, 6 | 4.33 | 5.97 | two dice |
| 4, 5, 6 | 9.91 | 11.43 | two dice |
The pattern: when the open tiles add up to 6 or less, one die is always the better roll, because two dice can never make a 1 and rarely make a 2. From a total of 7 upward, two dice usually win, since they can clear more in one go. There are exceptions, like 1, 2 and 4, where one die still wins because it can finish the round in pieces. For any position, the calculator at the top of this page gives the exact answer.
How good is "always take the highest tile"?
Very good. Taking the move that shuts the highest tile, and the fewest tiles on a tie, averages 11.23 on 9 tiles with the optional rule. That is within 0.22 points of perfect play. If you remember one rule, remember that one.
Picking moves at random is far worse: an average of 20.43 on 9 tiles and 49.70 on 12, with the box shut 2.06% and 0.03% of the time. Those match the 20.4 and 49.7 that Game On Family published. The gap between 20.4 and 11.0 is the part of the game you control.
The distribution of scores
Even with perfect play, most rounds don't end at zero. On 9 tiles with the optional rule, 9.67% of rounds end with the box shut, 2.74% with a score of 1 and 3.22% with 2. The most common non-zero score is 9, at 5.93%.
Thai style odds
In Thai style (also called Jackpot) you always roll two dice and shut exactly one tile equal to either die or their sum. Wikipedia quotes a strategy, the sum on a high tile if possible, otherwise the lowest tile, that shuts 7.9855% of games. We computed the best possible strategy: 7.9987%. The rule of thumb is almost perfect. The rules are on the variations page.
How the numbers were computed
A state is the set of open tiles: 512 states on a 9-tile box, 1,024 on 10 and 4,096 on 12. For each state the solver looks at every two-dice total (with its real chance, 1/36 for a 2 up to 6/36 for a 7) and every one-die roll the rule allows. It takes the best legal move for each roll, using values already worked out for states with fewer tiles, and averages over the rolls. When no move exists, the round ends and the score is counted. That is backward induction, and it gives exact answers.
Download the full tables as JSON: shut-the-box-solver.json. They hold the expected final score and the best chance of shutting for every state and rule set, plus Thai style. They are free to use under CC BY 4.0; please credit shuttheboxgames.com. Want to test yourself against the same dice as everyone else? Try the daily game, or practise on the home page with hints on.
FAQ
Questions people ask
Is there any strategy to Shut the Box?
Yes. It is mostly luck, but choosing which tiles to shut moves your average by about 9 points on 9 tiles: random legal moves average 20.4, best play 11.0.
What are the odds of shutting the box?
About 1 in 10 on a 9-tile box with good play and the optional one-die rule; 1 in 13 to 14 if the single die is compulsory or banned.
Can you actually win Shut the Box every time?
No. Some rolls can't be made whatever you do. Best play only lowers your average score.
What are the odds of shutting the box with 12 numbers?
About 1 in 211 with best play (optional one-die rule), 1 in 254 to 276 under the other rules.
Is it better to shut one big tile or several small ones?
Usually the big one. High tiles are hard to clear later, and small tiles are what you need at the end.
How rare is it to shut the box?
On 9 tiles, a careful player does it roughly once every 10 rounds.
Keep rolling
More ways to play
Shut the Box GamePlay solo on 9, 10 or 12 tiles, with hints if you want them.
Play With FriendsA free private room: send the link, everyone plays their own box.
Daily Shut the BoxSame dice for everyone today. Could you have shut the box?
Shut the Box RulesHow to play, scoring, the one-die rule and 2 to 4 players.
Variations12 tiles, 4-player boards, Thai style, digital scoring and more.
Math Game for KidsNumber bonds at every roll, a kids mode and classroom rules.
PrintablesScore sheet, paper board and a one-page rules PDF.